In-line suggestions

Have been using Posit Assistant with both RStudio and Positron for a while now. Overall I like it a lot and the agentic coding has been a game-changer (I do have a few minor suggestions but that can wait). My experience with the in-line suggestions is, however, not been the best.

My biggest complaint is that it's really hard to control.

  • Sometimes it says it has a suggestion but I couldn't see it
  • It overrides the backspace button and I often end up unintentionally deleting a whole paragraph I've written. It also overrides the cursor for some reason and I couldn't edit text in places anymore.
  • It doesn't seem to allow me to accept suggestions word by word (or did I miss something?)
  • The quality of suggestions are not quite up to standard compared to Github copilot, so I end up pressing ESC a lot.

For comparison, the UI of inline suggestions in the Github copilot + VS code setup seems much more intuitive (the only minor issue I had with that one is sometimes I want TAB to work as TAB instead of "accept suggestion"). Is it possible for Posit Assistant to model the UI of its inline suggestions after that?

Can confirm. Using Posit NES has almost rewired my brain to press ESC after every line of code to dismiss un-useful suggestions. Github Copilot provides way better suggestions (they are longer and more aware of code context) and are offered as simple ghost text, way better in my opinion. I don't think anybody needs to see a character-by-character diff of a code suggestion

Yeah, I ended up disabling NES in positron, might consider using it again if it improves, but for now it works smoother without.