that was good advice, because only color and colour are aesthetics and colors/colours (plural) are not.
aside from that you have a variable called P-value this will confuse R into thinking you have a variable called P and one called value and you want to subtract them ...
either
rename your variables in an earlier step , something like p_value would be good
if you need to refer to it with its current name use a pair of backticks to quote it so R knows its one symbol, like this